Want to hear a secret?

Stephanie Burt joins TFS with weekly Nightcap

"Bedtime Gossip" stereograph card, circa 1891/ All images via Library of Congress
"Bedtime Gossip" stereograph card, circa 1891/ All images via Library of Congress
Avatar photo
Avatar photo

It’s no exaggeration to say The Food Section exists to rejuvenate food news deserts across the American South.

In fact, that was the elevator pitch for the Substack Local grant which made this publication possible. Given 250 words to explain why I wanted to launch a newsletter, I concluded: In the South, where food is exceptionally important and culture is contested, the scarcity of true food journalism is shameful. My goal in starting this publication is to correct for this blind spot across communities.

(Granted, I also told the Substack team in my application that “I am confident that the quality of this product will facilitate growth,” which goes to show how little I knew back then about subscription models.)

But what I didn’t foresee on April 16, 2021 is that the region’s food news landscape would become even more desolate. While I worried about legacy media writing off food and drink as a lighthearted diversion, and online influencers helping to empower well-funded restaurants and their PR machines, it didn’t occur to me that digital listicles were in trouble.

Then, on December 5, 2024, Vox Media “implement(ed) role eliminations and organizational changes” at Eater, according to a memo from its CEO. In short, parent company Vox pink-slipped many of the editors overseeing the well-known brand’s 23 city sites, which include Eater Carolinas, Eater Nashville, and Eater New Orleans.

Somewhat deviously, Eater didn’t do away with those websites. Instead, it’s now populating supposedly local homepages with recycled material and press releases rewritten by regional editors. “It’s going to be a shell of its former self without a local editor running it,” former Detroit Free Press food critic Mark Kurlyandchik told Axios Detroit. “Who else is going to write about the women making masa out of their house from heirloom corn?”

Honestly, I don’t know who will pick up the slack in southeastern Michigan. But around here, it’s The Food Section’s mission to make sure the food journalism sector doesn’t shrink.

We’re tremendously excited to announce today that longtime Charleston food journalist Stephanie Burt is joining The Food Section as author of its new Nightcap newsletter, debuting on Monday, January 13.

As Lowcountry residents know, Stephanie’s institutional knowledge is unmatched. TFS readers will benefit enormously from her deep understanding of the city and informed appreciation of Southern cuisine.

So, what is the Nightcap newsletter? Unlike other TFS newsletters, which are typically devoted to a single narrative, it features a collection of short items about the Lowcountry’s food-and-beverage scene. It’s lively, buzzy, and very much of the moment: Nightcap aims to be your go-to source for what’s really going on when restaurants close, partnerships dissolve, and fancy events go awry. Nightcap is where readers will find out first which food truck is upgrading to a permanent location, and what an acclaimed out-of-town chef has in mind for her new Charleston bistro.

Years ago, Eater was known for that kind of must-read reportage. Yet as the site grew, it standardized its coverage across the country, with predictably weird results. City editors were sometimes tasked with coming up with lists of happy hours (still illegal in North Carolina), or places to patronize on a snowy day (South Carolina didn’t get a flake last winter.) While I made up those examples, they’re not far off the mark. The point is: Fun, highly localized food news disappeared.

Now, it’s back—in your inbox on Mondays at 8:43 p.m. Eastern.

In some ways, Nightcap represents a departure for TFS, which hasn’t before ventured into what could be dismissed as gossip. In other ways, though, the evening newsletter’s in keeping not just with TFS’ mission, but its defining spirit.

  • First, TFS has never shied away from using what’s worked for publications in the past. (Order a print edition here!) It’s odd to use the phrase “glorious history” alongside the term “tidbits,” but the very first newspaper published in the American colonies didn’t stint on scuttlebutt. While TFS would never sink to publishing baseless rumors about the king of France, it’s also not above acknowledging that there’s community interest in verified information about who’s coming, who’s going, and why.
  • Second, holding power to account means keeping tabs on powerful people and the places they patronize. In 2024, I read several histories of various publications (see previous bullet point), and one detail that stuck with me from Paper of Wreckage, an oral history of the New York Post, is it was a Page Six writer who recorded Bob Hope telling a grossly homophobic joke at a $1000-a-plate dinner held amid the AIDS crisis. While Hope was already seen as out-of-touch, that column is credited with hastening the end of his career. Way to go, fourth estate!
  • Third, and most importantly, TFS doesn’t buy into the idea that good journalism has to be boring. There are hundreds of local news startups preaching that the future of democracy hinges on their success, and I’m not about to take issue with that argument. But journalism is more than solemn coverage of meetings and dry analyses of documents. Even at very serious times, it can be dishy and impish and fun.

Thanks to the generous sponsorship of Pink Cactus, Nightcap will be free to read. But folks have to sign up to receive it! If you’re not already on The Food Section’s email list, you can add your address here.

blue-line

Comments

Comments

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Here's what else you missed in The Food Section this week

TFS is off, and the grill is on/ Photos by Hanna Raskin

Earning our keep (and summer break too)

See you in September!

This way to beachy wine/Photos by Hanna Raskin

Is Vino Feo the region’s best wine bar?

Call it a wine window, por favor

The crudo from Black Pearl in Ponte Vedra Beach/ Photos by Hanna Raskin

Blowing a fusion

Itameshi on the rise across the South